"Loosen's 2008 Erdener Treppchen Riesling Spatlese hasn't the impressive sheer delicacy of some other wines in its company, and whereas the corresponding Kabinett was especially striking for its lack of perceived sweetness, this Treppchen is the sweetest-tasting of any of this year's Loosen Spatlesen. While it lacks the deep-seated richness of the corresponding Wehlener or uncanny balance of the Urziger, it is nonetheless pure, lusciously citric and melony, suffused with high-toned herbal essences, and finishes with satisfying spice and hints of site-typical smokiness. It no doubt needs longer to emerge out from under its residual sugar than do its nearest siblings and should perform well for 15 or more years." - David Schildknecht