"A more racy style than many 2005s, this exudes apple, lime and slate notes (think margarita lite), backed by moderate acidity. A bit pinched on the finish, but expresses its origins." - Wine Spectator
"Relatively cool, lively, mineral, racy impact. Not one of the finest or sweetest. Competent." - Jancis Robinson
"This 2005 Scharzhofberger Riesling Spatlese displays more of a sweet herbal character in the nose than others of the wines tasted here. Hints of rather site-typical ripe peach and subtle slate emerge on the silky palate, with the continuing accompaniment of high-toned herbal essences. Refined and satisfying, this Riesling is nevertheless relatively herbal in focus and demure in length." - David Schildknecht (167, The Wine Advocate)
"Pale yellow. Smoky aromas of pear, sweet herbs and lemon candy.Glossy, plush apricot fruit is nicely framed by a harmonious mineral underpinning. Juicy and lush on the finish, with enough minerality to maintain a refreshing lightness." - Stephen Tanzer's International Wine Cellar
