Penfolds Wines PTY Ltd, Tununda Road, Nuriootpa SA 5355, Australia

• 95/100 Robert Parker
• 917,5/100 Jancis Robinson
• 95/100 Falstaff
• 93/100 Jeannie Cho Lee
• 92/100 Wine & Spirits Magazine
• 94/100 Wine Spectator
• 95/100 Jeremy Oliver
• 96/100 The Wine Front
• 94/100 Jamie Goode
• 93/100 CellarTracker

• 97/100 Robert Parker
• 18/20 Jancis Robinson
• 99/100 james Suckling
• 97/100 Falstaff
• 93/100 Wine Spectator
• 93/100 CellarTracker

• 93/100 Robert Parker
• 17/20 Jancis Robinson
• 93/100 Falstaff
• 94/100 Wine Enthusiast
• 95/100 Wine Spectator
• 93/100 The Wine Front
• 95/100 Jeremy Oliver
• 93/100 CellarTracker

• 94/100 Robert Parker
• 18/20 J. Robinson
• 92/100 Wine Enthusiast
• 95/100 The Wine Front
• 88/100 Decanter World Wine Awards
• 93/100 Jeremy Oliver

• 97/100 Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
• 96/100 James Suckling
• 94/100 Decanter
• 93/100 Wine Spectator
• 17/20 Jancis Robinson

• 96/100 Robert Parker
• 17/20 Jancis Robinson
• 93/100 Falstaff
• 91/100 Wine Spectator
• 91/100 Wine & Spirits Magazine
• 98/100 Bob Campbell
• 96/100 Jeremy Oliver
• 93/100 CellarTracker

• 90/100 Robert Parker
• 92/100 Wine & Spirits
• 17/20 Jancis Robinson
• 94/100 Falstaff
• 91/100 Jeremy Oliver
• 93/100 The Wine Front
• 92/100 CellarTracker

• 96/100 Robert Parker
• 96/100 Wine Spectrator
• 17,5/20 Jancis Robinson

• 96/100 Robert Parker
• 96/100 Wine Spectrator
• 17,5/20 Jancis Robinson

• 95/100 Robert Parkers Wine Advocate
• 95/100 Falstaff
• 92/100 Wine Enthusiast
• 96/100 Wine Spectator
• 95/100 The Wine Front
• 97/100 Jeremy Oliver
• 93/100 CellarTracker
• 17,5/20 Vinum Wine Magazine

• 95/100 Robert Parkers Wine Advocate
• 95/100 Falstaff
• 92/100 Wine Enthusiast
• 96/100 Wine Spectator
• 95/100 The Wine Front
• 97/100 Jeremy Oliver
• 93/100 CellarTracker
• 17,5/20 Vinum Wine Magazine

• 95/100 Parker
• 95/100 Suckling
• 96/100 Decanter

• 97/100 James Halliday
• 97/100 James Suckling
• 96/100 Decanter
• 95/100 Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
• 94/100 Wine Spectator
• 90/100 Wine Enthusiast

• 92+/100 Robert Parker's Wine Advocate

• 94/100 James Suckling
• 93/100 Wine Spectator
• 92/100 James Halliday
• 92/100 Stephen Tanzer
• 89/100 Robert Parker

• 96/100 Robert Parker
• 16,5/20 J. Robinson

• 94/100 Robert Parkers Wine Advocate
• 93/100 The Wine Front
• 94/100 Jeremy Oliver

• 94/100 Parker

• 90/100 Robert Parker
• 87/100 Jeannie Cho Lee
• 87/100 CellarTracker
• 88/100 Decanter

• 96/100 Robert Parker
• 98/100 Wine Spectrator
• 98/100 Falstaff
• 17,5/20 Jancis Robinson

• 96/100 Robert Parker
• 98/100 Wine Spectrator
• 98/100 Falstaff
• 17,5/20 Jancis Robinson

• 98/100 Robert Parker

• 100/100 Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
• 98/100 Decanter
• 97/100 Wine Spectator
• 95/100 Wine Enthusiast
• 18+/20 Jancis Robinson

• 99/100 James Halliday
• 99/100 Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
• 98/100 Decanter
• 98/100 James Suckling
• 98/100 Wine & Spirits

• 99/100 James Halliday
• 99/100 Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
• 98/100 Decanter
• 98/100 James Suckling
• 98/100 Wine & Spirits

• 99/100 Robert Parker
• 100/100 James Suckling
• 99/100 James Halliday

• 100/100 James Suckling
• 100/100 Falstaff
• 99/100 Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
• 99/100 Wine Enthusiast
• 98/100 Winespectator

2008:

• 100/100 Robert Parkers Wine Advocate
• 98/100 Falstaff
• 19/20 Jancis Robinson

2010:

• 100/100 Falstaff
• 99/100 Wine Enthusiast
• 98/100 Wine Spectator

• 90/100 The Wine Front
• 89/100 Cellar Tracker

• 90/100 Robert Parkers Wine Advocate
• 94/100 Falstaff
• 17,5/20 Jancis Robinson
• 93/100 James Suckling
• 93/100 Vinous
• 93/100 Wine Spectator